Doctor Who S8 Ep3: Robot of Sherwood

Legends really do exist!

The Doctor takes the TARDIS to Sherwood Forest to show Clara that Robin Hood is a myth. But is the dashing outlaw in green they meet really Robin Hood? And why is the Sheriff of Nottingham hoarding gold?

The Doctor and Clara meet the man behind the legend (Image: BBC)

The Doctor and Clara meet the man behind the legend (Image: BBC)

Too funny for its own good?

No damsels in distress. No pretty castles. No such thing as Robin Hood.

Doctor Who has always benefitted from an occasional injection of humour to provide levity between an episode’s big dramatic moments. However, when the pursuit of laughs comes at the expense of narrative the results are usually disappointing. (Case in point: the Ninth Doctor’s Slitheen two-parter Aliens of London/World War Three.)

In Robot of Sherwood, Mark Gatiss opts for thigh-slapping camp farce in his retelling of the legend of Robin Hood, and it just doesn’t work. It’s not that the banter between the Doctor and Robin (Da Vinci’s Demons’ Tom Riley) isn’t funny – much of it is. And after the darkness of the opening two episodes a bit of light to offset the shade makes for a welcome change. But the humour comes at the cost of characterisation and any sense of a coherent plot.

Are we really expected to believe that the Doctor can hold off a skilled swordsman such as Robin with a spoon? Yes, I know it’s a comic retelling of the traditional tale of Robin and Little John’s initial encounter, but come on.

Then the entire resolution to the story revolves around two conceits which require far too much of a suspension of disbelief.

Marian helps the Doctor rally the peasant slaves to overcome the alien robots by using silver trays to reflect their laser beams back on themselves with implausible accuracy. And then there’s the gold arrow won by the Doctor at the Sheriff of Nottingham‘s (Ben Miller) archery tournament, which turns out to be the difference that allows their ship to make orbit at the end. If scarce gold is so important to the robots’ attempts to repair their spacecraft, why waste some on a trophy?

Reflections on a hero

Remember, Doctor, I’m just as real as you are.

The one area where the story does work well is in portraying Robin as a mirror image of the Doctor, although the point is hammered home rather too heavily in the final scene. Both are heroic, rebellious and hide their true nature behind a mask – overt merriness in Robin’s case, whereas for the Doctor it is his changing faces which provide his disguise.

Also, there’s a tacit recognition that both men are incomplete without their companions – Clara and Marian – and better men when united with them.

The edited scene

The original episode included the Sheriff being (temporarily) beheaded near the beginning of the climactic battle, revealing that it is he and not Robin who is (partly) robotic. This was edited out 48 hours before transmission after the recent murders of two US journalists by Islamic State militants.

Although it doesn’t materially affect the outcome of the episode, it does explain why the Sheriff subsequently refers to himself as “first of a new breed: half man, half engine”, a statement which makes little sense without the context of his beheading.

Overall, this was an episode which lacked the dramatic oomph to balance out its funnier moments, one with a plot which was both plodding and predictable. For all Gatiss’s sharp wit and lovingly inserted references, the whole was so much less than the sum of its parts. Disappointing.

Fun stuff, references & quotables

  • The Doctor is seen scribbling on a blackboard again. That’s three episodes in a row.
  • He offers to take Clara to see the Ice Warrior hives. Their most recent appearance was in Cold War – an episode written by Gatiss.
  • I make Robin Hood the eleventh major historical figure to appear since the series’s return in 2005. Previously we’ve had three queens (Victoria, Elizabeth I, Nefertiti), three writers (Charles Dickens, William Shakespeare, Agatha Christie), two leaders of nations (Winston Churchill, Adolf Hitler), plus Madame de Pompadour and Vincent van Gogh.
  • The Doctor says he learned his fencing skills from Richard the Lionheart, Cyrano de Bergerac and Errol Flynn. The First Doctor met Richard in The Crusade, while his successor summoned Cyrano in The Mind Robber.
  • One of the Doctor’s early theories is that they may be trapped in a miniscope representation of Sherwood Forest. Miniscopes appeared in the Third Doctor story Carnival of Monsters – they were cylindrical micro-environment displaying the lives of miniaturised beings for the entertainment of others.
  • “Quickest way to find out anybody’s plans – get captured.”
  • “It is not a competition about who can die slower!”
  • Sheriff: “[I will be] King in all but name, for Nottingham is not enough. After this, Derby. Then Lincoln. And after Lincoln …” Clara: “Worksop?”
  • The Doctor calls the Sheriff a “pudding-headed primitive”. He also referred to Earth as “planet of the pudding brains” in Deep Breath.
  • Gatiss also incorporates a number of historical references:
    • The Sheriff’s plea of “Who will rid me of this turbulent Doctor?” echoes Henry II’s request about Thomas Becket, with ‘Doctor’ in place of ‘priest’.
    • “Do you really think your peasants’ revolt can stop me?” The Peasants’ Revolt was an uprising in England led by Wat Tyler in 1381.
    • The Doctor’s evaluation of Robin – “He’s the opiate of the masses” – is a quote attributed to Karl Marx, the father of Communism, in which he compares religion to the narcotic effects of opium.
  • “History is a burden. Stories can make us fly.”

Rating: 5/10

Doctor Who season 8 reviews

8.1 Deep Breath

8.2 Into the Dalek

Advertisements

5 Comments on Doctor Who S8 Ep3: Robot of Sherwood

  1. I liked it. While I agree with many of your quibbles I found this a superior outing to the first two.

    • Hi e, thanks for popping over. There were definitely bits I liked but the overt merriness, the Doctor’s childishness and the silliness of the resolution were just a bit too much for me. Although I have to admit that I found it less annoying second time round when watching it as a viewer rather than as a reviewer. Even so, just not my bag – although I suspect many people will have liked it, as you did.

      Next week’s trailer looks rather good, does it not? 🙂

  2. In my opinion, it sounds like a version of Blink~

  3. I enjoyed it for what it was, a harkening back to the fun runarounds like The Androids of Tara and The Time Warrior. It was basically a Tennant style historical with Capaldi. He’s less assured with the comedy than I’d expected and the bickering wore thin quickly but my kids loved it (my youngest stopped mid-Matt Smith but sat through all of this one) as, I imagine, will the more casual viewer who cares less about ‘Gallifrey’, paradoxes and The Promised Land. Not every week, but the show needs more eps like this, I’d say 2 or 3 a season. Gatiss has found his niche with this and The Crimson Horror – the comedy historical.

    • I agree the show needs a lighter episode or two to break up the heavy stuff, but this just went too far for me. I like my comedy but not at the expense of plot, and this felt so much like Deep Breath-lite (I mean, we all knew the Sheriff was the real robot the moment he appeared, right?) hat I found it really off-putting.

      Still, a lot of other people seem to have liked the episode, so who am I to argue? It just wasn’t my bag.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: